NY Attorney General Backs Away From Robert Brooks Case

New York Attorney General Letitia James has recused herself from a high-profile case amid concerns of conflict of interest, leaving questions about how the investigation will unfold.

At a Glance

Attorney General Letitia James has recused her office from a case due to potential conflict with representing correction officers.
Fourteen officers are under investigation in Robert Brooks’ death at Marcy Correctional Facility.
Onondaga County DA Bill Fitzpatrick has been appointed as special prosecutor.
Bodycam footage shows officers allegedly choking the handcuffed Brooks.

Background of the Case

New York Attorney General Letitia James announced her recusal from the investigation into the death of Robert Brooks, who was fatally beaten at Marcy Correctional Facility. Her office is representing correction officers implicated in related matters, thereby necessitating her withdrawal to ensure no conflict of interest undermines the integrity of the legal proceedings.

Brooks was serving a sentence for first-degree assault when the incident occurred. Preliminary findings by State Police investigators indicate asphyxia due to neck compression as the cause of death. Multiple ongoing investigations involve the State Police, FBI, and New York’s Commission of Correction.

NY AG recuses office from Robert Brooks casehttps://t.co/T1Hq8AW2Yb pic.twitter.com/th6Agktc0u

— NEWS10 ABC (@WTEN) January 2, 2025

The Decision to Recuse

The footage captures officers choking Brooks while he was restrained with handcuffs and shackles. Regarding her choice to recuse, James said, “This decision was made with the utmost respect for the integrity of this investigation, and we will ensure that there will not be any delays.” The move aims to prevent any potential hindrance in prosecution due to legal challenges.

The Onondaga County District Attorney’s Office, under Bill Fitzpatrick, will assume the role of special prosecutor. Fitzpatrick has mentioned he won’t comment until further actions are taken by the Grand Jury. James expressed confidence in Fitzpatrick’s capability, noting his office is “well resourced to handle this complex and large investigation.”

Impact of the Investigation

Previous accusations of inmate abuse have been leveled against some officers under investigation. Governor Kathy Hochul has started firing processes for the involved officers and a prison nurse, with suspensions without pay already in effect. James acknowledged the difficult period for Brooks’ family, voicing her condolences.

The investigation has drawn attention to the Attorney General’s role in overseeing law enforcement-related deaths, including corrections officers. It underscores concerns about potential conflicts hindering the full exercise of her powers when defending state workers. As the case continues under Fitzpatrick’s lead, time will tell how the investigation unfolds.